Remembering Truthfully
“A nation becomes stronger, not weaker,
when it is willing to examine itself honestly.”
I remember reading in No Future Without Forgiveness by Desmond Tutu that, despite everything his nation had endured, he deeply loved his country. That statement has stayed with me over the years.
When the horrors of apartheid in South Africa were exposed, the world witnessed stories of brutality, racism, stolen land, broken families, and systemic oppression. As chair of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, Tutu was called to help guide a wounded nation through one of the most difficult journeys imaginable—the journey toward healing. He understood that reconciliation could never be built upon denial or selective memory. It required truth telling, honest confession, accountability, and the courage to face the past without flinching.
Yet in the midst of all that pain, Tutu never abandoned his love for South Africa. His hope was not sentimental or rooted in blind nationalism. It was a hope grounded in the conviction that a nation courageous enough to confront its failures could also build a more just future. His patriotism was expressed not by pretending the wounds did not exist, but by believing they could be healed.
As we recently celebrated the 250th anniversary of the United States, I found myself reflecting on Tutu's example. There is much in our nation's history that deserves celebration. The ideals expressed in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution have inspired generations around the world. Millions have found opportunity, freedom, and hope here.
At the same time, honest patriotism requires us to acknowledge that not everyone has experienced America as "the land of the free and the home of the brave." For Indigenous peoples whose lands were taken, for enslaved Africans and their descendants, for immigrants who faced discrimination, and for communities that continue to experience injustice, the promise of liberty has often been incomplete. To celebrate our country faithfully means celebrating both our ideals and the ongoing work required to make those ideals a reality for everyone.
Patriotism and truth are not enemies. In fact, they depend upon one another. A nation becomes stronger, not weaker, when it is willing to examine itself honestly. We honor our country not by ignoring its failures, but by committing ourselves to correcting them. Love that refuses to tell the truth is merely sentiment. Love that confronts the truth seeks transformation.
As we begin gearing up for the midterm elections, PBMR, as we have in the past, will encourage our community to register and vote. Every election provides an opportunity to shape the future we hope to see. Yet I also recognize the expressions I sometimes receive when I ask young people whether they plan to vote. Often the response is one of indifference or resignation. There is a look that says, "Why should I? No one in office really cares about people like me."
“Love that refuses to tell the truth is merely sentiment. Love that confronts the truth seeks transformation.”
Although I do not share that conclusion, I understand where it comes from. For generations, communities like ours have too often been overlooked, marginalized, or treated as political afterthoughts. Broken promises and unmet needs have understandably produced skepticism.
Trust is difficult to build when experience has repeatedly taught people that their voices carry little weight.
Still, disengagement only guarantees that others will make decisions on our behalf. Voting is not simply an act of optimism; it is an act of responsibility and hope. It is one way we affirm that our voices matter and that our communities deserve to be seen, heard, and represented. Democracy is strongest when those who have historically been excluded insist on participating rather than withdrawing.
The theologian Miroslav Volf, in The End of Memory, reminds us that memory is essential to our identity. We become who we are, in part, through what we remember. But Volf also argues that we must remember truthfully. Distorted memories—whether they exaggerate our virtues or erase our failures—cannot bring healing. Honest memory does not imprison us in the past; rather, it frees us to learn from it and move toward reconciliation.
“Honest memory does not imprison us in the past; rather,
it frees us to learn from it and move toward reconciliation.”
That may be one of the greatest challenges facing our nation today. We must remember our history in all its complexity—its remarkable achievements and its profound failures. We celebrate what is noble. We repent where we have fallen short. We listen to voices that have too often been ignored. And we continue striving toward the ideals that have always been at the heart of the American experiment
Like Desmond Tutu, we can love our country without pretending it is perfect. In fact, perhaps the deepest form of patriotism is the willingness to love a nation enough to tell it the truth, to believe it can become better, and to commit ourselves to that work. Truth and hope belong together. Remembering truthfully is not about assigning perpetual guilt; it is about making genuine healing possible. Only then can we move toward the future with integrity, justice, and hope.


Reimagining Justice in Illinois: A Restorative Justice Blueprint for Illinois’ Criminal Legal System









